JEE Prep Master

Reading mode

Text size

JEE Main 23 January 2026 Shift 2: Chemistry Question 59

General Organic ChemistrySingle correct option+4 / −1

Given below are two statements:
Statement I\text{I}: (CH3)3C+{\text{(C}\text{H}_{\text{3}})}_{\text{3}}\text{C}^{+} is more stable than CH3+\text{C}\text{H}_{\text{3}}^{+} as nine hyperconjugation interactions are possible in (CH3)3C+{\text{(C}\text{H}_{\text{3}})}_{\text{3}}\text{C}^{+}.
Statement II\text{II}: CH3+\text{C}\text{H}_{\text{3}}^{+} is less stable than (CH3)3C+{\text{(C}\text{H}_{\text{3}})}_{\text{3}}\text{C}^{+} as only three hyperconjugation interactions are possible in CH3+\text{C}\text{H}_{\text{3}}^{+}.
In the light of the above statements, choose the correct answer from the options given below

Show answer and solution

Correct answer: Option 4

Hyperconjugation of an alkyl carbocation involves donation from a C\text{C}–H σ\text{H }\sigma bond on a carbon adjacent to the positively charged carbon into its vacant p\text{p} orbital.

The tert-butyl cation, (CH3)3C+{\text{(C}\text{H}_{\text{3}})}_{\text{3}}\text{C}^{+}, has three adjacent methyl groups, contributing 3 × 3 = 9\text{3 }\times \text{ 3 = 9} such C\text{C}–H\text{H} bonds. This stabilisation, together with alkyl electron donation, makes it more stable than the methyl cation. Statement I is true.

The methyl cation CH3+\text{C}\text{H}_{\text{3}}^{+} has no adjacent carbon at all, so it has zero of these hyperconjugative C\text{C}–H\text{H} interactions. Its three C\text{C}–H\text{H} bonds are attached to the positively charged carbon itself and are not the required adjacent C\text{C}–H\text{H} donors.

Statement II gives a correct stability order but a false explanation//count, so it is false as a whole. Choose option 4\text{4}.

More General Organic Chemistry questions

All 54 General Organic Chemistry questions