Let C0=ε0dA and use the usual parallel-plate approximation, neglecting fringing at dielectric boundaries. Each half-area column is in parallel with the other. A column containing two half-thickness dielectric layers has those layers in series.
For a mixed column of area 2A, the two layer capacitances are k1C0 and k2C0. Their series equivalent is Cmix=C0k1(k1+k2)k2. A homogeneous half-area column filled with ki has capacitance ki2C0.
Thus CA=C0[2k1+k1(k1+k2)k2], CB=C0[2k2+k1(k1+k2)k2], and CC=C0[2k1(k1+k2)k2].
Subtraction yields CA − CC=C0k1(k1 − k2)/[2(k1 +k2)]>0 and CC − CB=C0k2(k1 − k2)/[2(k1 +k2)]>0. Hence CA>CC>CB, option 4.