JEE Main 2 April 2025 Shift 1: Chemistry Question 65
Designate whether each of the following compounds is aromatic or not aromatic.

Show answer and solution
Correct answer: Option 2
For a planar cyclic system with continuous p-orbital overlap, Hückel aromaticity requires π electrons. A carbanion contributes its p lone pair, whereas a carbocation contributes an empty p orbital and no π electrons.
(a), cyclopentadienyl anion, has π electrons and is aromatic. (b), cyclopentadienyl cation, has 4 π electrons and is not aromatic. The four-membered dication (c) has 2 π electrons and the corresponding dianion (d) has both satisfy the planar Hückel count.
(e), tropylium cation, has 6 π electrons and is aromatic. (f), cyclooctatetraene, has 8 π electrons and adopts a nonplanar tub shape, so it is nonaromatic. (g), cyclobutadiene, has 4 π electrons and is antiaromatic in the planar conjugated description. (h), cyclopropenyl cation, has 2 π electrons and is aromatic.
Thus the aromatic set is a, c, d, e and h; b, f and g are not aromatic. “Not aromatic” here includes both antiaromatic and nonaromatic cases. Select option (2).
