JEE Prep Master

Reading mode

Text size

JEE Main 28 January 2025 Shift 1: Physics Question 34

ThermodynamicsSingle correct option+4 / −1

A Carnot engine (E) is working between two temperatures 473 K and 273 K. In a new system two engines: engine E1E_{1} works between 473 K to 373 K and engine E2E_{2} works between 373 K to 273 K. If η12,η1\eta_{12},\eta_{1} and η2\eta_{2} are the efficiencies of the engines E,E1E,E_{1} and E2,E_{2}, respectively, then

Show answer and solution

Correct answer: Option 4

For a Carnot engine η=1−TcTh.\eta = 1 - \frac{T_{c}}{T_{h}}. Thus η12=200473,η1=100473\eta_{12} = \frac{200}{473},\eta_{1} = \frac{100}{473} and η2=100373.\eta_{2} = \frac{100}{373}.

More generally, (1−η1)(1−η2)=(373473)(273373)=273473=1−η12.\left( 1 - \eta_{1} \right)\left( 1 - \eta_{2} \right) = \left( \frac{373}{473} \right)\left( \frac{273}{373} \right) = \frac{273}{473} = 1 - \eta_{12}. Therefore η12=η1+η2−η1η2.\eta_{12} = \eta_{1} + \eta_{2} - \eta_{1}\eta_{2}.

Both component efficiencies are positive, so their product is positive and η12<η1+η2.\eta_{12} < \eta_{1} + \eta_{2}. These component engines are understood to be Carnot engines; efficiencies of arbitrary irreversible engines would not be fixed by their reservoir temperatures.

More Thermodynamics questions

All 41 Thermodynamics questions